On-demand webinar60 minutesConstructionHosted by ENR

2022 survey results discussed: how automation is unlocking new value in construction

Tucker Fife of Branagh and Rick Dowell of Pontem Innovations join FlowForma’s Paul Stone and Conor McGrath to unpack FlowForma’s survey of 100 US construction decision-makers: how much still runs on paper, what gets in the way, and how to choose processes, drive adoption and prove ROI.

What does the ENR webinar cover?

2022 Survey Results Discussed: How Automation Is Unlocking New Value in Construction is a 60-minute on-demand webinar from FlowForma, the no-code process automation platform native to Microsoft 365, hosted by Engineering News-Record on August 4, 2022. A general contractor and a FlowForma partner react to eight findings from FlowForma’s survey of US construction firms. See FlowForma for construction.

63%say digitization is a top priority
96%say real-time analytics informs senior management decisions
87%believe digitization gives construction firms a competitive advantage
74%expect 50–100% of their processes to be digitized within 18 months

Source: FlowForma survey of 100 decision-makers at US construction firms, 2022.

What the ENR audience told us

Two live polls asked attendees how much of their work still runs on paper, email or spreadsheets, and what their biggest process challenge is.

51–75%

of processes on paper, email or spreadsheets: the audience’s top answer

Roughly what percentage of your business processes are managed on paper, email or spreadsheets?

  • 1–25%
  • 26–50%
  • 51–75%Top answer
  • 76–100%
“If you have a great subcontractor you trust and like working with, you can’t leave them behind because of your digitization.”Tucker Fife, Branagh

Live poll at 07:27. FlowForma’s survey found 26–75% is typical.

Top 2

challenges in FlowForma’s survey: security of remote data access, and reliance on paper

What is your biggest challenge with processes?

  • Reliance on paper-heavy data
  • Restricted communication with staff, customers and suppliers
  • No single overview of business processes
  • Difficulty engaging with external parties
  • Poor data and reporting
“We came to understand how our business runs, and the pressure points in our processes, more than we ever had before.”Tucker Fife, Branagh

Live poll at 17:43. The poll results weren’t read out.

Want to see it with your processes?

Book a demo with our process experts and see how your teams can take site, subcontractor and reporting processes off paper and spreadsheets.

  • A demo built around one of your processes
  • Subcontractor onboarding, site reports or owner reporting
  • Advice on integrating with Procore, finance and other systems
  • No cost and no obligation

Working in construction? See FlowForma for construction

Pick a time that suits you

00:00

Welcome and speakers

Watch this part

Ellen McCurtain00:00

Good afternoon, and welcome to this webinar, 2022 Survey Results Discussed: How Automation Is Unlocking New Value in Construction. This event is brought to you by Engineering News-Record and sponsored by FlowForma. I’m Ellen McCurtain, custom content editor for ENR.

Ellen McCurtain00:16

More than 100 key construction decision-makers in the US were recently surveyed to understand how their organizations develop and execute strategies for more orderly, productive and profitable outcomes by automating business processes. Today we’ll analyze the results, our guests will share their approach to digitization, and you’ll learn how to take control of construction outcomes, minimize risk and protect profits with process automation.

Ellen McCurtain00:58

Conor McGrath is a digital marketing executive at FlowForma, where he creates thought leadership content and resources on transforming business processes. Paul Stone is product evangelist and strategist at FlowForma. He supports clients and internal teams, and manages and communicates the product roadmap.

Ellen McCurtain01:47

Joining them is Rick Dowell, president and co-founder of Pontem Innovations, who has an extensive background in senior operational leadership and board governance. And Tucker Fife, real estate financial analyst at Branagh Development. Tucker joined Branagh in 2019. As well as underwriting and helping obtain entitlements for development projects, he automates processes across Branagh’s lines of business, most recently with FlowForma as they moved onto SharePoint.

03:00

About the survey

Watch this part

Conor McGrath03:00

Thanks, Ellen. FlowForma surveyed 100 decision-makers at US construction firms about the state of digitization in the industry, with an emphasis on workflow and business processes. Today we’ll talk through what we found. Please join in the polls and send us your questions for the Q&A. You can also download the full survey report from the handouts section.

04:06

Finding 1: how much still runs on paper

Watch this part

Conor McGrath04:06

Our first finding: typically 26 to 75 percent of a construction company’s business processes are managed on paper, in email or on spreadsheets. Tucker, is that something you’ve come across?

Tucker Fife04:33

That band is very unsurprising. Most construction companies want to update their processes and know the benefits of digitization, but the nature of the business makes a total transformation extremely challenging. As a general contractor, Branagh coordinates with subcontractors and consultants across many trades, each with their own level of technological know-how and their own platforms. If you have a great subcontractor you trust and like working with, you can’t leave them behind because of your digitization.

Rick Dowell06:22

That matches our experience at Pontem. Most project sites are away from the office, with different companies on site at different levels of sophistication, and the tools available even three to five years ago couldn’t meet all those stakeholders’ needs. That has changed. FlowForma is a good example of something more seamless that meets people where they are, so everybody can use the same process. Organizations that tried before should take another look.

07:27

Poll: how much runs on paper, email or spreadsheets?

Watch this part

Conor McGrath07:27

Our first poll asks roughly what percentage of your business processes are managed on paper, email or spreadsheets: 1 to 25 percent, 26 to 50, 51 to 75, or 76 to 100.

Conor McGrath08:30

The results are in, and 51 to 75 percent is the leading answer, so what we’ve just been discussing is still very prevalent.

08:53

Finding 2: digitization is a top priority

Watch this part

Conor McGrath08:53

Next, we asked whether digitization is important or a top priority. 63 percent said it’s a top priority and another 30 percent said it’s important. Paul, is that what you see?

Paul Stone09:24

It’s really encouraging to see the figure so high. It means people realize processes are key to their operations and drive them toward their business goals. In the past, how to digitize them was a mystery: if you’re stuck on paper and spreadsheets, or using a system without a process engine, it’s very difficult. Digital processes are an easy way to get a return on your technology investment, because they’re directly tied to business goals and you can measure them.

Rick Dowell11:12

I’d say it’s a top-two priority for most organizations. Executives look three to five years ahead, and the characteristics of a successful organization then include digital processes, using data effectively, real-time reporting, and automating the manual, repetitive tasks that take up administration time without adding value. And the tools available now are far less scary and time-intensive than they were three years ago.

12:36

Finding 3: the challenges firms face

Watch this part

Conor McGrath12:36

We asked what challenges construction firms face. Security of remote data access and reliance on paper-heavy processes are the top two.

Tucker Fife13:18

Reliance on paper is definitely a struggle in our digitization and automation efforts on the construction side. People like hard copies, especially of plans, and that fosters reliance on other paper processes. The best way I’ve found to challenge it is to build automations that don’t just match what paper does but surpass it in ways that matter to the user, not only to management.

Tucker Fife14:44

I was a little surprised by the security concerns. With some common-sense best practices, a huge benefit of moving onto SharePoint and Office 365 is that our data is far more secure. Paper can be compromised or stolen in more ways than you’d think.

Paul Stone16:10

I’d have expected interaction with external parties to rank higher. Combined with paper reliance, it’s a significant challenge, because paper gets lost in transit between people. Our clients see a big benefit when that exchange happens electronically. And I agree with Tucker: cloud systems like SharePoint and FlowForma, with encryption everywhere, are a good deal more secure than paper.

17:43

Poll: your biggest process challenge

Watch this part

Conor McGrath17:43

Our second poll asks what your biggest challenge with processes is: reliance on paper-heavy data; restricted communication with staff, customers and suppliers; no single overview of business processes; difficulty engaging with external parties; or poor data and reporting.

Paul Stone18:54

The inability to generate a single overview of business processes is interesting. It ties to transparency, visibility and gathering the data for reporting.

Tucker Fife19:08

A beneficial side effect of bringing FlowForma in was that, in trying to generate that single overview, we came to understand how our business runs, and the pressure points in our processes, more than we ever had before.

19:48

Finding 4: obstacles to transformation

Watch this part

Conor McGrath19:48

Our fourth finding covers the obstacles to transformation. Tucker, do any stand out?

Tucker Fife20:36

IT and talent was a big struggle for us early on. We outsource IT to a third-party company that does an excellent job, but this was outside their wheelhouse, so we brought in a consultant to explore different products, which took a couple of months and a reasonable amount of resources. In the data, what stands out is how high satisfaction with current processes is, relative to management priority and lacking an internal champion. Perhaps firms are broadly happy with their processes, with one or two people pushing them forward.

Rick Dowell22:53

What I found encouraging is that not being a management priority and lacking an internal champion are quite low, so organizations have people who want to push this forward. As for 50 percent being satisfied with current processes, that’s often a change management issue rather than proof the process is good. When we implement FlowForma, processes are often optimized as we build: people tell us they always wanted to make an improvement that wasn’t possible before. There’s lots of room for improvement.

24:42

Finding 5: real-time analytics

Watch this part

Conor McGrath24:42

Our fifth finding: 96 percent of construction executives report that real-time analytics informs senior management decision-making.

Rick Dowell25:13

At Pontem we help organizations use their data more effectively. On a project with many systems from different subcontractors, a lag in data causes problems and usually needs manual work just to tie it together. If you get an early warning of an issue a month in advance, you have a lot of options. If you see it a month after it happened, your options are limited, and usually not good.

Rick Dowell26:18

FlowForma makes data input consistent and sustainable: it’s automated, in the same format and in the same place, such as SharePoint, so you can tie it into dashboards and track the metrics you need. It helps decisions at every level, not just senior management. A site lead, superintendent or project manager can see what’s happening on their project and compare it with others. People make really good decisions when the data in front of them is valid and accurate.

Paul Stone27:46

Analytics is a topic with our clients every day. By digitizing processes you capture all the data in real time, accurate and up to date. One civil engineering client, on a 31-kilometer stretch of highway, needed a permit to dig for every nine-square-meter area. They issued the permits through FlowForma and, with real-time analytics, could see where they could dig each day and address bottlenecks as they happened.

29:30

Finding 6: what firms require from a solution

Watch this part

Conor McGrath29:30

Next, we asked what’s most required when considering a digital solution. Ease of use is absolutely required for 60 percent, and efficiency ranks highly too.

Paul Stone30:18

Everybody wants efficiency as a key deliverable, because that’s how you see a return on investment. FlowForma helps you implement processes and monitor them, so you can measure how efficient a process is, change it to improve it, and measure the improvement over time.

Tucker Fife31:36

Efficiency is why we started digitizing and automating. But building automations is a balancing act between how powerful and efficient a workflow is and how easy it is to use. You want to cut out as many steps as possible, but the second it’s too hard to use, no one uses it and you’ve lost the efficiency.

Rick Dowell33:31

No-code matters because the business process owner can change a process to get the information they need, which translates straight into real-time reporting. That’s really difficult in a code environment. In construction no two projects are the same, so you need to keep adjusting processes as requirements evolve.

34:28

Finding 7: systems to integrate with

Watch this part

Conor McGrath34:28

We asked which systems construction firms most want to integrate with. Project management software tops the list.

Rick Dowell34:58

Employees don’t want to go to multiple systems; they want information populated automatically. One client had to fill in the same eight boilerplate details, like project number, location and client, on forms for different stakeholders. We now populate those automatically, saving five to ten minutes per form. A consistent look and feel across departments also makes change management easier.

Paul Stone37:30

Any business process tends to require integration with multiple systems, and we’ve focused on making those integrations quick and easy, with specific integrations for construction, such as Procore, and back-end systems like SAP. Often the bottleneck is going into system A, then B, then C. FlowForma passes information into those systems automatically as you move through the process.

38:51

Finding 8: the infrastructure act

Watch this part

Conor McGrath38:51

Our final finding: 85 percent of construction executives think the $1.2 trillion infrastructure act will affect their project pipeline this year and next.

Tucker Fife39:32

Branagh won’t compete for these contracts, but anyone ignoring a $1.2 trillion investment does their business a disservice. It will create fierce competition, and the leanest, most streamlined companies, the ones that can do more with less, will come out on top more often than not. Process automation is a huge factor in that. We’re watching how our peers in infrastructure win these contracts, so we can adapt and not get left behind when they enter other markets.

Rick Dowell41:30

Government expectations of transparency on how this money is spent are only increasing, so your processes and reporting can set you apart. Clients of ours with significant owner reporting requirements now simply pull a report from data coming in daily through FlowForma forms, rather than someone compiling it manually in Excel every week.

42:57

Four key stats

Watch this part

Conor McGrath42:57

To summarize four key stats: 63 percent say digitization is a top priority; 87 percent believe it gives construction firms a competitive advantage; 90 percent still use outdated methods such as email, Excel and paper; and 74 percent believe 50 to 100 percent of their business processes will be digitized within the next 18 months.

44:25

About FlowForma

Watch this part

Paul Stone44:33

FlowForma is an award-winning process automation provider, with many construction customers in the US, the UK, Australia and elsewhere, on small and large projects. The system combines digital processes, the steps people carry out on the ground, with data collection forms and document generation, saving documents in SharePoint. Incident management and health and safety are big areas, along with quality, resources, and onboarding and offboarding.

Paul Stone46:16

Our clients range from large government projects like Tideway in the UK to firms focused on areas like building restoration. FlowForma doesn’t specialize in one process or one type of construction. It’s flexible, so you can build whatever process you need for your environment.

47:41

Q&A: three tips for user adoption

Watch this part

Conor McGrath47:49

Our first question: what are your top three tips for user adoption? Rick?

Rick Dowell48:11

First, engage users in building processes early. It removes the big-bang go-live and makes change management much easier. Second, start with a small or medium-sized process rather than your biggest, so you get a quick win that builds enthusiasm. Third, pick a process where analytics and reporting can measure the improvement, so you can show people where you’ve improved and where the next bottleneck is.

51:07

Q&A: how to prioritize which processes to automate

Watch this part

Conor McGrath51:07

Tucker, any tips to help prioritize which processes to automate?

Tucker Fife51:25

The obvious approach is a greedy one: estimate the time and cost of each candidate process now and after automation, sort the list and work top to bottom. It’s hard to go too wrong, but it ignores some externalities. If your vendor offers a support period where they build your first workflow with you, as FlowForma does, it can be worth swinging for the fences on complexity, because there’s a difference between how hard a flow is to build and how hard it is to use.

Tucker Fife53:06

Also, maximize the chance of people outside your automation team suggesting processes. Our best ideas come from the people using our processes. And look beyond time saved: FlowForma has let us cancel some software expenses by building custom solutions instead. We recently canceled a very expensive construction project management software because we recreated those tools in FlowForma.

54:48

Q&A: how soon will I see ROI?

Watch this part

Conor McGrath54:48

How soon could I see ROI from a tool like FlowForma? Paul?

Paul Stone55:04

ROI depends on how fast you get a process up and running and in use in the field. Some clients do it in one week; more typically it’s four to six weeks. As soon as it’s in use you’re generating ROI, and the system captures the metrics so you can see it. It depends on complexity: sometimes a more complex process is right, but often a simpler process used by as many people as possible is better.

56:19

Q&A: do email and Excel count as digitized?

Watch this part

Conor McGrath56:19

Logan asks: do you consider email and Excel digitized, even though they’re outdated?

Paul Stone56:36

Technically, maybe, but you’re not hitting the mark for what’s available today. A dedicated business process management system like FlowForma does much more for efficiency, for tracking processes and for reporting on the data captured along the way.

Rick Dowell57:27

Excel isn’t scalable. If you’re trying to bring it enterprise-wide, it won’t work.

57:43

Close

Watch this part

Conor McGrath57:43

We’ve had lots of questions, and we’ll answer the rest after the session. Thanks to Tucker, Rick and Paul.

Ellen McCurtain58:16

Please join me in thanking Conor McGrath, Paul Stone, Tucker Fife and Rick Dowell, and our sponsor, FlowForma. You’ll find more resources from FlowForma in the handouts tab, and the archive of this presentation at enr.com/webinars.

Frequently asked questions

What did FlowForma’s 2022 construction survey find?

FlowForma surveyed 100 decision-makers at US construction firms. 63% said digitization is a top priority, 87% said it gives firms a competitive advantage, 96% said real-time analytics informs senior management decisions, and 90% still use outdated methods such as email, Excel and paper.

What are the top tips for user adoption?

Rick Dowell of Pontem Innovations recommends three: involve users in building processes from the start, begin with a small or medium-sized process for a quick win, and pick a process where reporting can measure the improvement.

How do you prioritize which processes to automate?

Tucker Fife of Branagh suggests ranking processes by time and cost saved, using your vendor’s support period to tackle a more complex first workflow, collecting ideas from the people using your processes, and counting software you can retire.

How soon can you see ROI from FlowForma?

ROI starts once a process is live and in use. Some clients get a first process running in one week; more typically it takes four to six weeks, depending on complexity.

Is data in the cloud less secure than paper?

Both Tucker Fife and Paul Stone argued the opposite. With common-sense best practices, data in SharePoint and Microsoft 365 is far more secure than paper, which can be lost in transit, misplaced or stolen.

Do email and Excel count as digitized processes?

Technically, perhaps, but they fall well short. A dedicated process platform tracks every step and reports on the data captured, and Excel doesn’t scale enterprise-wide.

Ready to take your construction processes off paper?

Book a tailored demo built around your subcontractor, site or reporting process.